Local Column
COLUMN
Which Is Better: Miyako Island or Ishigaki Island? Local staff with offices on both islands compare the differences and transportation options.
Hello everyone!
One of the largest activity stores in Miyako Island
Miyako Island ADVENTURE PiPiIt is!
When thinking about a trip to the remote islands of Okinawa, I imagine many people find themselves wondering, “Should I go to Miyako Island or Ishigaki Island?”
Both are popular islands known for their beautiful blue seas, but,The island's topography and the ways to enjoy sightseeing there vary greatly.The following is a list of the most common problems with the "C" in the "C" column.
ADVENTURE PiPi has locations on both Miyako Island and Ishigaki Island and offers tours on each island.
In this article, local staff who are familiar with both islands will explain the differences between Miyako Island and Ishigaki Island, offer recommendations for various activities, and present a sample itinerary for visiting both islands.
Table of Contents
A Side-by-Side Comparison of the Differences Between Miyako Island and Ishigaki Island
First, I’ve summarized the main differences between Miyako Island and Ishigaki Island in a table.
| Item | Miyako Island (Okinawa) | Ishigaki Island |
| Area of the island | Approximately 159 km² | Approximately 222 km² |
| Population (City) | Approx. 53,000 | Approximately 47,000 people |
| Number of Tourists | Approximately 1.26 million people (FY 2025, Miyako region) | Approximately 1.51 million people (2025, Yaeyama Islands as a whole) |
| Major Cities with Direct Flights | Haneda, Chubu, Kansai, Naha (Miyako Airport) Haneda, Kobe, Fukuoka, Naha (Shimojishima Airport) |
Haneda, Narita, Chubu, Kansai, Fukuoka, Naha |
| Travel Time for Direct Flights (Outbound) | About 3 hours from Haneda About 2.5 hours from Kansai |
About 3 hours from Haneda About 2 hours and 45 minutes from Kansai |
| Estimated Airfare | It varies significantly depending on the time of year and when you make your reservation. Compare flights between Miyako Airport and Shimojishima Airport |
It varies significantly depending on the time of year and when you make your reservation. There are many direct flight routes, offering a wide range of options |
| Recommended Length of Stay | 2 nights, 3 days or more— | 3 nights, 4 days or more (if you're visiting remote islands) |
| Topography | A flat island with almost no mountains or rivers | It is home to Mount Omoto, the highest peak in Okinawa Prefecture |
| Characteristics of the Ocean | The crystal-clear sea known as "Miyako Blue" | Scenery where mountains and the sea come together, such as at Kabira Bay |
| Features of Diving | There are many spots where you can enjoy the natural features, such as caves and arches. | A famous spot for encountering manta rays |
| Local Delicacies | Miyako Beef, Miyako Soba, and Mangoes | Ishigaki Beef, Yaeyama Soba, Pineapple |
| Surrounding Islands | Connected by bridges to Irabu Island, Shimoji Island, Ikema Island, and Kurima Island | You can take a boat to the remote islands of the Yaeyama archipelago, such as Taketomi Island and Iriomote Island. |
| Distance from Naha | Approximately 290 km | Approximately 410 km |
The area isGeospatial Information Authority of Japan, the population isEstimated Population of Okinawa Prefecture, the number of tourists in Okinawa Prefecture isMiyako Region・YaeyamaIt is based on the statistics from [...].
Direct flights are,Miyako Airport・Shimojishima Airport・Minami-no-Shima Ishigaki AirportI checked the timetable (as of October 2026).
To put it simply,If you're mainly interested in beach activities, choose Miyako Island; if you want to explore the outlying islands and enjoy the natural beauty of the mountains, choose Ishigaki Island.is recommended.
From here on, we'll explain the differences between them in detail.
Differences in Island Size, Topography, and Towns
Ishigaki Island is a bit larger than the other island, andThe third-largest island in Okinawa PrefectureIt is.
Miyako Island has an area of approximately 159 km², while Ishigaki Island has an area of approximately 222 km² (as of April 2026; Source:Geospatial Information Authority of Japan）。
The population of Miyako City is approximately 53,000, while that of Ishigaki City is approximately 47,000, making them roughly the same size (as of September 2026; Source:Estimated Population of Okinawa Prefecture）。
Miyako Island is a flat island connected by bridges
Miyako Island is an island formed from uplifted coral reefs; it is flat across its entire surface and has almost no major rivers.
Since soil does not wash in from the mountains and rivers,The water rarely becomes murky and has high visibility.is a feature of this product.
Bridges connect Miyako Island to Irabu Island, Ikema Island, and Kurima Island, and you can also drive to Shimoji Island, which lies beyond Irabu Island.
The Irabu Bridge, which opened in 2015, is 3,540 meters long and, according to the Miyako Island Tourism Association, is the longest bridge in Japan that can be crossed for free.
Ishigaki Island has mountains and serves as the gateway to the Yaeyama Islands
On Ishigaki Island, at an elevation of 526 meters,Mt. Omoto, the Highest Peak in Okinawa Prefecture...so you can enjoy both the greenery of the mountains and the ocean views at the same time.
The southern part of the island is home to a bustling downtown area with a concentration of restaurants and souvenir shops.
Ferries depart from the Ishigaki Port Remote Islands Terminal for Taketomi Island, Iriomote Island, Kohama Island, Kuro Island, Hatoma Island, and Hateruma Island, andThe Gateway to the Yaeyama IslandsThe company is now in the process of
The Difference Between the Ocean and Tourist Attractions
Both Miyako Island and Ishigaki Island are surrounded by crystal-clear waters.
Just,The color of the ocean, the atmosphere of the scenery, and the types of popular tourist attractionsThere are differences.
The Ocean and Tourist Attractions of Miyako Island
The ocean around Miyako Island ranges from crystal-clear blue to “Miyako blueIt is called "the
There are beautiful beaches all over the island, including Yonaha Maehama Beach, with its 7-kilometer stretch of white sand, and beaches where you can encounter sea turtles.
Driving across the bridge is also a popular activity, and the view of the road stretching straight out over the ocean is something unique to Miyako Island.
・Irabu Bridge: A 3,540-meter-long bridge spanning the ocean
・Yonaha Maehama Beach: A white sandy beach overlooking the Kurima Bridge
・Higashi-Hezanazaki: A cape offering views of the Pacific Ocean and the East China Sea
・Pumpkin Cave: A cave with pumpkin-shaped stalactites that can be accessed from the sea
The Ocean and Tourist Attractions on Ishigaki Island
The sea around Ishigaki Island is captivating for its scenery, which combines the green mountains, white sandy beaches, and blue ocean.
According to the Ishigaki City Tourism and Exchange Association, Kabira Bay, a nationally designated scenic spot,Three stars in the Michelin Green GuideIt is a scenic spot that has won an award.
Since you can take a day trip by boat to the outlying islands, you can enjoy different ocean views on each island in a single trip.
・Kawahira Bay: A scenic spot where you can view the underwater world from a glass-bottom boat
・Blue Cave: A cave that glows blue, accessible by snorkeling
・The Phantom Island: A sandbar that appears only at low tide (accessible by boat)
・Taketomi Island: A remote island just a short boat ride from Ishigaki Island, featuring a townscape with red-tiled roofs
Which Is Better: Miyako Island or Ishigaki Island? Recommendations by Purpose and Occasion
Which island is right for you depends on what you want to do on your trip.
By purpose,Which island would you recommend?I've compiled the information.
・People who want to enjoy water activities like snorkeling and SUP to the fullest
・People who want to drive around the islands connected by bridges in a rental car
・People who want to swim with sea turtles
・People who want to relax on the beach
・People who want to venture out to the remote islands of the Yaeyama archipelago, such as Taketomi Island and Iriomote Island
・People who want to enjoy nature beyond the ocean, such as Kabira Bay, the mountains, and mangroves
・People who want to enjoy dining and shopping in the city
Miyako Island is a great choice for traveling with kids.
If you're traveling with children or infants,Miyako Island, where you don't have to travel faris recommended.
One of the great things about Miyako Island is that it’s flat, the beaches are close together, and it’s easy to get around by rental car, so kids don’t get tired as easily.
PiPi's sea turtle snorkeling tour is open to children ages 3 and up, and participants start in shallow water where they can touch the bottom while wearing life jackets.
Even on Ishigaki Island, PiPi’s “Mysterious Island” landing and snorkeling tour is open to children ages 3 and up, so parents and children can enjoy the scenery of the remote islands together.
Choose a Couples' Trip Based on How You Want to Spend Your Time
A couple's trip is,You can have a great time on either island.However, it's easier to decide if you base your choice on how you want to spend your time.
If you want to take your time enjoying the scenery together—such as driving across the Irabu Bridge or the Kurima Bridge, or visiting a beach where you can watch the sunset—we recommend Miyako Island.
If you want to visit a different island every day—whether it’s landing on the “Phantom Island” or strolling through the streets of Taketomi Island—Ishigaki Island is the perfect choice.
Ishigaki Island: A Great Place to Explore on Your Own
If you're traveling alone,Ishigaki Island, where restaurants and the remote island terminal are concentrated in the city centerIt's easy to move around.
The Ishigaki Port Remote Islands Terminal is located in the city center, and since ferries to Taketomi Island and Iriomote Island depart from here, it’s easy to take a trip to the remote islands even if you’re traveling alone.
If you're traveling alone on Miyako Island, we recommend renting a car so you can freely explore the islands connected by bridges.
Distance Between Miyako Island and Ishigaki Island and Transportation Options
Miyako Island and Ishigaki Island are about 120 km apart as the crow flies.
The distance from the Okinawa Prefecture Miyako Office to the Yaeyama Joint Government Building (Ishigaki City) is 122 km (Source:Okinawa Prefecture Miyako Office, “Overview of Miyako”）。
If you're traveling between the two islands,The general rule is to take a planeIt is.
Flights operated by RAC (Ryukyu Air Commuter) and ANA run between Miyako Airport and New Ishigaki Airport, and the flight time is about 30 to 35 minutes.
According to the October 2026 schedule, there are three one-way flights per day (Source:Miyako Airport・Minami-no-Shima Ishigaki Airport(Timetable).
There are currently no scheduled ferries carrying tourists between Miyako Island and Ishigaki Island.
① Since there are no scheduled flights from Shimojishima Airport to Ishigaki Island, use Miyako Airport instead.
② Since there are only a few departures, be sure to make your reservation early.
③ Since the number of flights and schedules vary by season, be sure to check the airline's latest information.
④ On windy days, flights may be canceled or delayed, so be sure to allow plenty of time in your schedule.
Sample Itinerary for Visiting Both Miyako Island and Ishigaki Island (4 Nights, 5 Days)
If you're going to both islands,4-night, 5-day trip: 2 nights on Miyako Island → 2 nights on Ishigaki Islandis recommended.
The flight between Miyako Airport and New Ishigaki Airport takes about 30 to 35 minutes, so even on the day of your transfer, you’ll have half a day to sightsee.
| schedule | island | how to spend one's time |
| Day 1 | Miyako Island (Okinawa) | Take a direct flight to Miyako Airport. Drive across the Irabu Bridge to Yonaha Maehama Beach. |
| 2nd day | Miyako Island (Okinawa) | Enjoy the "Miyako Blue" waters with PiPi's sea turtle snorkeling and SUP tours |
| Day 3 | Miyako Island → Ishigaki Island | I'll take the morning flight to New Ishigaki Airport. In the afternoon, I'll go sightseeing in the northern part of the island, including Kabira Bay. |
| Day 4 | Ishigaki Island | Join PiPi's "Mysterious Island" Landing Tour, or take a boat to Taketomi Island |
| Day 5 | Ishigaki Island | We bought souvenirs in town and headed home on a direct flight from New Ishigaki Airport. |
Since ADVENTURE PiPi has stores on both Miyako Island and Ishigaki Island,Join a PiPi tour on either islandCan be done.
When planning a trip to both islands, keep the following points in mind.
① Since there are only three one-way flights per day between Miyako Airport and New Ishigaki Airport, be sure to book your tickets early.
② You must rent and return a car on each island (cars cannot be transported between islands)
③ It’s also okay to take the reverse route—arriving on Ishigaki Island and departing from Miyako Island.
④ On the day you're traveling between the two islands, leave some extra time and don't schedule any tours.
Recommended Activities to Enjoy on Miyako Island
If you're visiting Miyako Island, we also recommend activities that let you experience the "Miyako Blue" ocean.
Here, at Miyako Island ADVENTURE PiPi,Especially Popular ToursHere are three examples.
Sea turtle snorkeling
This is a snorkeling tour where you can swim with sea turtles in the waters off Miyako Island.
Even if you can't swim, please wear a life jacketStart in shallow water where you can touch the bottomSo you can rest assured.
The activity takes about 2 hours, and is suitable for ages 3 to 59.
SUP on a spectacular beach
This is a tour where you can take a leisurely paddle on a SUP across the crystal-clear, Miyako-blue sea.
From the top of the boardCoral and fish in the oceanYou might even see it.
The activity takes about 2 hours, and is suitable for ages 3 to 59.
Miyako Island Complete Plan
This is a one-day package that lets you experience four activities: SUP, snorkeling, exploring the Pumpkin Limestone Cave, and canoeing.
For those who want to make the most of Miyako Island’s ocean in a single dayIt's perfect for that.
Recommended Activities to Enjoy on Ishigaki Island
If you're going to Ishigaki Island,The "Phantom Island" accessible only by boat, Kabira Bay, and the Blue CaveWe recommend tours where you can enjoy [...].
Here, we’ll introduce two popular tours offered by ADVENTURE PiPi on Ishigaki Island.
Landing on a Legendary Island & Snorkeling
This is a tour where you take a boat to "Phantom Island (Hamajima)," a sandbar that appears only at low tide.
In the waters surrounding the island,Snorkeling Among Coral Reefs and Tropical FishYou can also enjoy
The tour lasts about 3 hours (including travel time) and is suitable for ages 3 to 59.
Kawahira Bay SUP/Canoeing & Blue Cave Snorkeling
This one-day tour lets you enjoy stand-up paddleboarding and canoeing in Kabira Bay—which has been awarded three stars in the Michelin Green Guide—as well as snorkeling at the Blue Cave.
For those who want to visit Ishigaki Island’s two must-see attractions in a single dayIt's perfect for that.
The tour lasts approximately 7 hours (including breaks and transportation time), and is open to participants ages 5 to 59.
Frequently Asked Questions About Miyako Island and Ishigaki Island
Please choose one that suits your travel plans.
The flight between the two islands takes about 30 to 35 minutes.
When traveling between the two islands, take a flight between Miyako Airport and New Ishigaki Airport.
The population of Miyako City is approximately 53,000, while that of Ishigaki City is approximately 47,000, so they are roughly the same.
For a 4-night, 5-day trip, you can spend 2 nights on Miyako Island and 2 nights on Ishigaki Island, allowing you to enjoy both islands at a leisurely pace.
If you plan to visit both islands, a trip of at least 4 nights and 5 days will allow you to enjoy yourself without feeling rushed by travel.
PiPi's tours also start in shallow water where you can touch the bottom while wearing a life jacket, so they're easy for children to join.
in the end
In this article, we highlighted the differences between Miyako Island and Ishigaki Island, provided recommendations for different occasions, and introduced a sample itinerary for visiting both islands.
If you want to enjoy the ocean to the fullest, choose Miyako Island; if you’d like to explore the outlying islands and enjoy the natural beauty of the mountains, choose Ishigaki Island. Please choose the island that best suits your travel plans.
Both Miyako Island ADVENTURE PiPi and Ishigaki Island ADVENTURE PiPi offer ocean tours on both islands.
Thank you for taking the time to read this to the end.
This article was written by.
